Master
planning is perhaps the most overlooked technique
that a church can use to save time, money, and a
lot of frustration. Churches are ideal candidates
for master planning because they typically construct
their facilities in phases over a long period of
time.
A simple
definition of a master plan is that it is a design
of everything that the church plans to build on
a particular site.
Master
plans are usually composed of site plans, floor
plans, exterior views of the building, and artistic
renderings that depict the project in its various
phases. It may also include budgets, strategies,
schedules and an architectural model of the completed
project.
I like
to use the analogy of a jigsaw puzzle to help people
understand how a master plan works. To create
the puzzle, you must first have a picture, which
is then cut into pieces. These are then put
back together piece by piece, all fitting perfectly,
to recreate the picture. The master plan is
the picture, which is then broken down into its
various phases of construction. As each phase
is constructed, the "pieces" fit together properly.
By knowing
what each component of the master plan will be,
costly mistakes and needless expenses can be prevented.
For
example, it is much less expensive to construct
a building so that the floor of the entire building
is at the same level. Even a 1' difference
in elevation from one floor to another can cost
tens of thousands of dollars because of the cost
of constructing stairs and ramps for wheelchair
users. If each addition to the building were
at different levels, these costs would multiply
by many times.
For
similar reasons, coordinating the floor elevation
of the building with the topography of the site
can eliminate the need to construct exterior stairs
and ramps. Not only are these very costly,
but they also present liability and safety hazards
as well.
Providing
properly sized utilities, such as water, sewer,
power, and natural gas are also big money-savers,
because if they are sized for the full project,
they will only have to be installed once.
Knowing
where an elevator will be installed in the future
means that all of the structure and fire-rated walls
can be constructed in advance, eliminating a costly
retrofit later.
Those
are just a few of the many examples of how a master
plan can save money on construction. But it
provides many other benefits, too.
Master
planning allows a church to be frugal with the amount
of construction that is done. In other words,
every part of the master plan has a purpose that
has been identified, justified and quantified.
There
are four things that need to be in balance with
each other in order to accomplish this. These
are 1) worship space, 2) educational space, 3) fellowship
space and 4) parking. A church's attendance
will tend to stabilize with the smallest of these
four denominators. If, for example, the sanctuary
seats 500 people, but there is only enough parking
for 200, attendance will tend to stay around 200.
A frugal design will keep these capacities in balance
to the greatest degree possible, creating economy
and efficiency.
Sometimes
when churches build, they find that an important
part of their existing building becomes unusable
during construction. This can mean months
of chaos as the church does a stressful juggling
act in an attempt to keep everything going.
The master plan should be designed to keep worship,
education, fellowship and parking in balance and
in operation during this time, so that the church
never skips a beat.
A good
master plan will effectively communicate the vision
for the project to everyone in the congregation.
We tend
to be a forgetful people, and we need reminders
to keep us focused. If this vision is not
clearly communicated on a continual basis to the
congregation, all of the hard work and planning
that was initially done on the master plan will
be lost.
Therefore,
it is critical to keep the master plan displayed
where everyone in the church will come into contact
with it.
Since
one of the goals of the master plan will be to stimulate
growth, there will be a constant flow of new people
into the church. The master plan is very useful
for acquainting them with the goals of the church,
and to gain their moral and financial support.
Although
most of the technical work of the master plan is
done by the architect, the congregation will spend
a great deal of time preparing the criteria for
the architect. This can be a valuable time
of prayer and thought that can edify the church.
Jesus
said, "Suppose one of you wants to build a tower.
Will he not first sit down and estimate the cost
to see if he has enough money to complete it? For
if he lays the foundation and is not able to finish
it, everyone who sees it will ridicule him, saying,
'This fellow began to build and was not able to
finish." (Luke 14:28-30).
This
was actually an analogy about counting the cost
of being His disciple, but there is a clear principle
in this example that I think is applicable to our
building programs.
It is
important that the master plan be done with a great
deal of care. If, for example, you make assumptions
without having sufficient knowledge, make decisions
without doing proper research, or deliberately attempt
to circumvent laws (like building codes), you could
be setting yourself up for disaster. Even
worse, you may find yourself with an unfinished
project on display for the world to see. I
can think of at least two occasions where churches
have been forced to stop their construction by building
officials, leading to a great deal of embarrassment.
One of them, over five years later, is still unfinished.
Once
a realistic master plan is completed, it is important
to follow through with it. This does not mean
that course corrections can not be done. As
new needs arise or new technologies become available,
the master plan should be flexible enough to allow
changes without harming the overall integrity of
the plan.
A good
master plan is a great tool, and in a way serves
as an insurance policy against failure. Every
church should have one.