On July 17, 1981, between
1,500 and 2,000 people gathered at the Kansas City Hyatt Regency
Hotel to see a dance contest that was sponsored by a local radio
station.
Inside the Hyatt was an
atrium area with two "skywalks" that were over 100 feet long that
overlooked the dance floor. The skywalks were fully occupied
with spectators, watching the dance below.
At 7:05 pm, a loud cracking
noise filled the room, and within seconds the walkways plummeted
down, killing 114 people, and injuring over two hundred
others.
This wasn't the first
collapse that had occurred at the Hyatt. Two years before the
completion of its construction, the atrium roof had collapsed.
Improper expansion joints and structural connections were blamed for
the collapse. After the investigation was completed,
construction continued with the suspension of the skywalks.
Then, just a year after construction was complete, the skywalks
collapsed.
The explanation of why the
collapse happened is really very simple, but a bit technical, so
bear with me. I'll give you a practical example after the
technical stuff so that it will be easy to understand.
The original design called
for a row of six steel rods to be suspended from the atrium ceiling
structure that would support the entire length of the
walkways. The bottom thirty feet of the rods were to be
threaded to accept washers and nuts. The upper walkway would
be constructed on the floor, then lifted up to its final height with
the rods slipping through holes in its support structure. Nuts
and washers would then be spun up to the bottom of the
structure. Once the nuts were in place, then the temporary
supports for the walkway could be removed, and the lower walkway
would be installed the same way.
Conceptually, the design
worked, but in reality, it proved to be somewhat difficult and
expensive to do. No one wanted to twist a threading die over a
thirty feet length on the steel rods.
The fabricators saw a way to
avoid threading the rods. They suggested that they suspend the
rods down only far enough to support the upper walkway. That
way they would only have to thread the bottom six inches of the
rod. To support the lower walkway, they suggested that they
suspend the steel rods from the upper walkway. This would only
require threading the rod for six inches at the top and six inches
at the bottom.
What the fabricator did not
realize was that instead of the load of the lower walkway being
transmitted through the rod to the roof structure, its load was
being placed on the upper walkway.
Think of it this way.
Two men are hanging from a rope. One is hanging onto the end
of the rope, and the other is halfway up the rope, barely hanging on
for dear life. The guy on the bottom climbs up the rope and
grabs hold of the man above him. Now the top guy is not only
holding his own weight, but also the weight of the other man.
He isn't strong enough to hold the added weight, loses his grip, and
falls. This is exactly what happened at the Hyatt
Regency.
There were other factors that contributed to the
collapse, aside from the design change.
First, the earlier collapse
of the atrium should have been a big clue that there was something
systemically wrong with the design and construction
team.
Second, investigators found
that the original design of the walkways was grossly under-designed
to begin with, so the design change aggravated that condition right
away.
Third, the shop drawings (the
drawings that are used to fabricate all the parts and pieces) were
given to a junior engineer at the structural engineer's office to
check. He saw that the rods and beams were the same size that
his office had specified, but did not notice the difference in the
design.
After the collapse, two
structural engineers had their licenses permanently revoked for
gross negligence and unprofessional conduct. As you would
expect, lawsuits against everyone involved, including the building
owner, went on for years, resulting in millions of dollars.
The reports were that everyone's insurance was "limited
out".
The tragedy of this collapse,
besides the loss of life and injuries, was that a series of
easily-recognized mistakes had been made by a series of people who
were either incompetent or lazy, or both. Thankfully, this
doesn't happen very often.