Home
Projects

Architectural Services

Master Planning
Articles by R.W. Bright
Pre-drawn Plans
Staff
 

The Failing Power Grid

Last week I wrote about an alternative power source, wind power. I believe that we need to be pursuing this and other alternative power sources so that we can reduce our dependency upon foreign oil sources.

But there is another problem that we need to address. Our power grid, now over 55 years old, is in dire need of an upgrade to keep up with the increasing demand for electricity. If we could make the switch from gasoline to electric cars now, it is doubtful that our power grid could keep up with so much more demand without increasing the capacity and reliability of our power grid.

According to the National Science Academy, from 1993 to 2003, electrical demand grew by 35 percent, but power capacity only grew by 18 percent.

The most recent power grid failure occurred barely one year ago when lightning knocked out a power station on the United States side of the Niagra River. The failure of that station quickly cascaded, causin massive power failures throughout the Northeast, from the eastern coast to as far away as Cleveland, Ohio and as far north as Toronto. Ten nuclear power stations were forced down in the process, as well as other power sources. About 9,300 square miles was affected by the blackout, cutting off power to about 50 million people.

The public takes electricity for granted, and was basically unaware of the fragile nature of our power grid until last year’s massive blackout. For the most part, they are still unaware. But scientists and engineers have known about this problem for many years.

In the May-June 2000 issue of the American Scientist magazine, Thomas J. Overbye, an associate professor of electrical and computer engineering at the University of Illinois (Champaign-Urbana campus) was quoted to have said, “The reliability of America's power grid, which has to date been unequaled anywhere in the world, is increasingly at risk… highly interconnected to assure a power supply and predictable prices even when major components fail or demand soars, the electric network is governed by the laws of physics as much as economics. No part of the grid is sheltered from changes or failures in other parts…”.

The power grid for all of North America is, for the most part, one big circuit whose greatest strength is also its biggest weakness. Its strength comes from having all generators providing power to the grid, so that if one goes out, the others can pick up the load.

However, its weakness was demonstrated in the blackout last year. When one component fails, it can trigger failures in other components over vast areas at nearly the speed of light.

Last year’s failure was not the first. There was a massive blackout in 1965 in the Northeast that affected 30 million people. There were also blackouts in the Western US in 1994 and 1996, and another in the Eastern US in 1999.

Governor Bill Richardson of New Mexico, who served as the energy secretary in the Clinton administration, said that “despite being a superpower, we have a grid that is comparable to a third world country”.

Deregulation in the 1990’s created incentives fo power companies to build additional power plants and to upgrade their systems, but few power companies have taken advantage of the incentives. The cost of making the improvements simply isn’t profitable.

What this all means is that we can expect for more failures to occur as more demand is placed upon the grid and as the grid components continue to age.

For homeowners, churches and businesses, this means that to keep the power on, they must take responsibility for providing their own power during those down times.

The market has recognized this need and is responding. Emergency generators are now widely available (or at least were until the hurricanes hit Florida), and can be purchased at building supply stores. The cost of the generators depend upon the power output, so there is a wide range of generators that are affordable for homeowners, churches and small businesses.

The generators are designed to turn on automatically after the power has been out for a period of a few seconds, and are fueled by propane or natural gas. They are also programmed to turn on periodically to verify that they are in running order.

These are not the kind of units that should be used as a primary source of electricity. Their greatest value is that they will allow your home, business or church to continue operations during the inevitable power failures.


 

   
8-1-2005    ©2006 Randy W. Bright, AIA, NCARB, Church Architect
4821 So. Sheridan Suite 209 • Tulsa, Oklahoma 74145 • Phone No. 918-664-7957 • Fax No. 918-622-0097• Email