Home
Projects

Architectural Services

Master Planning
Articles by R.W. Bright
Pre-drawn Plans
Staff
 

When Crowds Kill, Some OK Legislators want to reduce safety

I recently was sent a notice that a bill is being prepared that, if passed, will greatly reduce the safety requirements in Oklahoma buildings, especially in rural towns. The bill will basically exempt all towns under a population of 5,000 from using an architect on any building. That means churches, schools, stadiums, restaurants, everything, could be built without meeting code. That also means about 90 percent of Oklahoma, since our state is made up of largely small towns.

This bill would eventually lead to unsafe design conditions, and would create a situation where a disaster will be waiting to happen.

Last year, when at the capitol, I was told that there has been resistance by a key legislator to tighten up our laws, who did not believe that safety was an issue in Oklahoma. He reportedly said, (I am paraphrasing) “show me the bodies, then we’ll do something about it”.

Well, here are the bodies. You can find a whole list of them at http://www.crowddynamics.com/Main/Crowddisasters.html, but here is just a partial list of what you will find at that website.

In 1902, 26 people were killed and 500 were injured when a grandstand collapsed in Glasgow.
It happened again in 1961 in Glasgow, when another grandstand collapsed, killing 3 and injuring 35.
In 1964, 300 died at an Olympic qualifying match. When a referee made an unpopular call, the crowd rioted, and the deaths occurred during the resulting stampede of panicking people from the stadium.
In 1968, 74 people died in a stampede in a stadium in Buenos Aires. The deaths occurred at a locked exit door.
In 1982, 340 people died in a stampede at a European Cup Match in Moscow.
In 1990, 1,426 people died in Mecca, Saudi Arabia, when people panicked in an overcrowded pedestrian tunnel.
In 1992, 50 were injured in Rio de Janerio when they fell from an upper level seating area when a fence gave way.
In 1996, 83 were killed and 160 injured during a World Cup qualifying match in Guatamala City.
In 1999, 53 people were killed when a crowd raced to get out of the rain at a train station in Belarus.
In 2000, 9 people in Denmark were killed at a concert when they slipped and fell in mud in front of a stage. They were trampled by the crowd.
In 2001, 47 were killed and hundreds injured by crushing crowds at the Ellis Park Stadium in Johannasburg, South Africa. 120,000 people had pressed into a stadium that was only intended to hold 68,000.
In 2002, 21 children died in Beijing, China, when a guard rail gave way in a stairwell when the lights went out in a power failure.
In 2004, 51 died at a wedding in Bombay, India when decorations caught fire in a temple.

On August 3rd of last year, a fire broke out in a supermarket in Asuncion, Paraguay, the result of a gas explosion. As panicked patrons rushed toward the exits, the owner reported ordered the doors to be locked to prevent people from leaving without paying. As a result, over three hundred people died, and over a hundred were injured, some seriously. They owner, his son, and the security guards were placed under arrest pending the investigation.

So far all of these happened in other countries? Why do you suppose that is?

In the United States, we have been using the building codes to preemptively save lives for many years. The codes work, if there is someone who knows how to use and apply them, and if they are enforced. Virtually all of the examples in this article may have been prevented if the facilities had been properly designed.

We have had our share of disastrous fires and crushing tragedies. I have written a number of articles about large casualty fires and other situations that have occurred here in America.

These kinds of things happen when the codes are not used. Any of these situations could happen in any school in Oklahoma. That is exactly what can happen if our legislators do not do something to require that buildings meet code in this state.

Please call your State Representative and your State Senator and let them know how important this is. We don’t want Oklahoma to become a third-world country when it comes to safety.

 

   
8-1-2005    ©2006 Randy W. Bright, AIA, NCARB, Church Architect
4821 So. Sheridan Suite 209 • Tulsa, Oklahoma 74145 • Phone No. 918-664-7957 • Fax No. 918-622-0097• Email